Skip to Main Content

Core Academic Study Skills Framework

banner

evaluating information

Intro

Level one

Introductory

  • Understand the difference between a primary and secondary source
  • Identify strengths and weaknesses of source material
  • Evaluate the quality of information (print and electronic) using criteria such as bias, authority, currency, validity, etc.
  • Distinguish between good quality and other sources
  • Recognise the limitations of Google and Wikipedia for the purposes of academic study
  • Awareness of Bibliometrics

Level two

Intermediate

  • Identify your information gap – be aware of what you don’t yet know
  • Seek multiple perspectives and viewpoints during information gathering and assessment
  • Recognise the choices you have made in your use of sources, and understand how currency, relevance, accuracy, authority, reliability and purpose of these sources has influenced your decisions
  • Understand the importance of the peer review process for journal articles
  • Compare and contrast the evidence, assessing any gaps or weaknesses
  • Use bibliometrics to select & evaluate information
  • Have a basic understanding of the publishing process & the currency of information

Level three

Advanced

  • Clearly define the scope of a research question and apply relevant criteria to filter large quantities of information
  • Use advanced methods, such as a systematic review to answer your research question
  • Follow the development of an area of research, comparing and contrasting evidence, and synthesising information to form connections and build your own arguments
  • Articulate and justify the decisions you have made in choosing and using sources appropriate to your information needs
  • Reflect on the research process, assess whether the information need has been met, and redefine as necessary